When most people think of St. George Island, they picture miles of white sandy beaches, gentle Gulf waves, and a relaxing escape from busy life. But this part of Florida’s Forgotten Coast also holds centuries of history, much of it filled with mystery, tragedy, and legends that still linger today.
Exploring these legends offers a different perspective on the island and its surrounding towns. They aren’t just ghost stories—they’re glimpses into the hardships, triumphs, and tragedies that shaped this coast.
If you’re looking for memorable things to do on St. George Island, adding a ghost adventure to your beach getaway makes for an unforgettable experience.
Cape St. George Lighthouse
The Cape St. George Lighthouse is perhaps the most iconic symbol of the island. The original tower was built in 1833 on what was once known as Little St. George Island. Over the decades, storms, erosion, and hurricanes destroyed the lighthouse three separate times. The current reconstruction stands proudly today thanks to local efforts, preserving the memory of its long, turbulent past.
Many say the spirits of past lighthouse keepers never left. Stories tell of footsteps echoing in the stairwell when no one else is inside. Some visitors report feeling sudden cold drafts despite the Florida heat. There are even accounts of lantern lights swaying in the tower when the building is empty. The idea that generations of keepers remain tied to their post is a common theme among lighthouse legends across the country, and Cape St. George is no exception.
Beyond the legends, visiting the lighthouse is a must for history lovers. Climbing the stairs to the top gives you panoramic views of the Gulf of Mexico, Apalachicola Bay, and the barrier islands. It’s a mix of breathtaking beauty and an undercurrent of mystery that will stay with you long after you descend.
Chestnut Street Cemetery
A short drive from St. George Island takes you to Apalachicola, home to the historic Chestnut Street Cemetery. Dating back to 1831, it is the final resting place of many of the town’s earliest residents, including sea captains, merchants, and families struck down by yellow fever epidemics. Walking through the cemetery feels like stepping into another century, with weathered gravestones that tell stories of hardship and resilience.
Local accounts say the cemetery comes alive at dusk. Visitors have reported hearing whispers that seem to come from nowhere, as if conversations of the past still linger on the breeze. Others claim to have seen faint figures moving between the tombstones before vanishing without a trace. Even skeptics admit there’s an undeniable atmosphere in the cemetery, particularly when the Spanish moss sways above you and the sun dips low on the horizon.
Beyond the ghost stories, Chestnut Street Cemetery offers a valuable look at the area’s history. Each headstone reflects the struggles of early settlers who braved storms, disease, and isolation to carve out a community on Florida’s Gulf Coast. For those interested in history or genealogy, it’s one of the most meaningful stops near the island.
The Orman House Historic State Park
Another Apalachicola landmark steeped in history and legend is the Orman House, built in 1838 by cotton merchant Thomas Orman. At the time, Apalachicola was a booming port city, and the Orman family lived in luxury compared to many of their neighbors. Today, the home stands as part of a state park, carefully preserved to showcase the grandeur of the 19th century.
But like many old homes, it also has its share of ghost stories. Guests and staff alike have reported unusual occurrences—doors opening and closing without explanation, mysterious cold spots, and even the faint smell of pipe tobacco lingering in rooms where no one has smoked in decades. Footsteps are sometimes heard on the wooden staircase when no one is visible.
Some say Thomas Orman himself still walks the halls, overseeing the house he poured so much pride into. Others believe the spirits of household staff remain tied to the property. Whether you believe or not, the combination of historical detail and eerie atmosphere makes the Orman House a fascinating stop.
The Raney House Museum
The Raney House, built in the same year as the Orman House, tells a different story of Apalachicola’s past. David Greenway Raney, another successful cotton merchant, constructed this elegant Greek Revival home in 1838. Today, the Raney House Museum is filled with antiques, documents, and artifacts that tell the story of the city’s growth during the 19th century.
The ghost stories tied to the Raney House add another layer to its appeal. Some visitors claim they’ve seen objects move on their own or heard voices echoing in empty rooms. One legend says David Raney’s wife, Harriet, never left the home she loved so dearly. Reports of her presence include sightings of a woman’s shadowy figure gliding through the hallways.
Even if you don’t encounter anything supernatural, the museum is worth a visit for its preservation of Florida history. The stories—both real and legendary—bring the home to life in a way that sticks with you. It’s easy to imagine the voices of the past echoing through its walls.
Ghost Tours near St. George Island
If you’d like a guided experience, there are two popular ghost tours in Apalachicola, just a short drive from the island. Both blend history and legend, giving visitors a chance to explore the area after dark in a completely different way.
Apalach Ghost Tour is a year-round walking tour that starts downtown near the Dixie Theatre. Lasting about an hour and a half, it takes guests through some of the city’s most haunted spots. Guides share stories of pirates, shipwrecks, and local tragedies, while participants can use EMF meters and other ghost-hunting tools along the way. Seasonal offerings, like the “Boos & Booze” haunted pub crawl, add even more excitement.
Another option is the Chestnut Street Cemetery Ghost Walk, typically held in late October. The Apalachicola Area Historical Society hosts this event and features volunteers dressed in period costume who share the life stories of early residents buried there. The combination of candlelight, historic setting, and dramatic storytelling creates a truly atmospheric experience.
For those staying in St. George Island vacation rentals, these tours are a fun way to add something different to your trip. They provide both entertainment and a deeper understanding of the history that shaped the Forgotten Coast.
Plan Your Next Visit
Are you ready to explore things to do on St. George Island during your next vacation? Browse our entire selection of beachfront St. George Island rentals today and find the perfect match for your stay!
Book Your St. George Island Rental with Fickling Vacation Rentals
After a day—or night—of exploring haunted lighthouses, cemeteries, and historic homes, you’ll want a comfortable retreat to return to. That’s where Fickling Vacation Rentals comes in. We offer a wide variety of St. George Island rentals, from cozy one-bedroom cottages to spacious beachfront houses perfect for families or groups.
Each property is thoughtfully maintained to give you the best of both worlds: the comfort of home and the beauty of Florida’s Gulf Coast right outside your door. Staying close to the island’s attractions makes it easy to balance relaxation with adventure. Spend your days soaking up the sun, your evenings exploring local legends, and your nights unwinding in a space designed for comfort.
Booking with Fickling Vacation Rentals ensures your trip is stress-free from start to finish. Our team is here to help you find the perfect property for your needs, whether you’re planning a romantic getaway, a family trip, or a group vacation. Start planning your stay today and experience not only the beaches of St. George Island but also the history and legends that make this coast so unique.
Sources
- Florida State Parks – Orman House Historic State Park
- Florida State Parks – Raney House Museum
- Cape St. George Lighthouse Association
- Apalachicola Main Street – Ghost Tours
Apalachicola Historical Society – Chestnut Street Cemetery
